Ask a Political Scientist: How far left is the Democratic party really?

Ask a Political Scientist: How far left is the Democratic party really?
Photo courtesy of Sara Rushing.

Editor's Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the MSU Exponent, its editorial staff, advisers, or Montana State University.

QUESTION: In leftist circles, I've often heard that the Democratic party in the US is really a center-right party. However, in right-leaning discourse, Democrats are described as radical, and very far left. How does this square with political theory? Can you provide any historical context that clarifies this disconnect in understandings? 

ANSWER: Great question! 

Ideology is a wily minx! While not totally “in the eye of the beholder,” judgments about what counts as liberal, conservative, radical or reactionary can be pretty subjective. To many Republicans, Barack Obama was socialism personified, particularly when it came to healthcare. To many Democrats, Obama was a neoliberal centrist introducing market solutions to a political problem, by mandating individual purchase of health insurance to address a systemic and social failure. Some people think Donald Trump is conservative, but many classical conservatives disagree completely! (As a traditional conservative columnist wrote in the New York Times this week, “There is no Trumpism…only Mr. Trump, following instincts and impulses that hew to no identifiable ideology.”) 

In the U.S., we’ve typically regarded the contemporary (i.e. late 20th/21st century) Democratic Party as “liberal” and Republican Party as “conservative.” In terms of “Modern” political theory (meaning late 16th – 19th century, or broadly the period of the Protestant Reformation, the Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution), “Liberalism” emerged as the ideology of individual rights and liberties, limited but strong government, and increasing popular sovereignty (Power to the People! No Kings!). That captures almost everyone today. 

Conservatives, historically, were skeptical about the powers of human reason to envision some totally different social and political order, and to scrap what existed (say, by revolution) and start from scratch. Conservatives tend to defer to the past and tradition, learn from history and human experience and make slow, steady, small-scale changes to laws, institutions and processes when it’s clear that such changes are already culturally underway. Liberals have tended to look ahead to the future and embrace opportunities to engineer progress toward some ideal — “Justice!” “Freedom!” Or…Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité!, as the French Revolutionaries proclaimed. 

Obviously, these theoretical ideologies do not map tidily onto our contemporary American political parties! Republicans scream “Less government!” But one of the biggest expansions of government since the FDR years was George W. Bush’s creation of the Department of Homeland Security. Liberals scream “More social safety net!” But Bill Clinton’s welfare reform policies made accessing these services harder and deployed the conservative rhetoric of “personal responsibility” to do so. 

The conventional wisdom is that the center of gravity in American politics has moved to the right since the 1970s. But the devil is in the details! The Democratic Party has actually moved a tiny bit to the left since the 1990s, but the Republican Party has moved a lot to the right. As far as the Democratic Party (which your question asks about) goes, I’ve seen it described as a “precarious electoral coalition of… highly-educated metropolitan professionals and the multiracial, primarily nonindustrial working class.” I’ve also seen it described as “a coalition of White Liberals, and non-white voters the majority of whom think of themselves as moderate or conservative.” And while the left is celebrating a truly historic “blue wave” last week, which will possibly bring nine new Democratic Socialists of America-backed Representatives to Congress, it looks like there will be twice as many new conservative Democrats joining the team, and the current hot take is that moderates out-performed more progressive candidates. 

So, what can we conclude about what the Democratic Party is “really like”? It’s complicated! And at a cross-roads! It’s pretty clear what voters in the 2026 mid-terms were voting against! But what the Party will come to stand for is another question. And can it successfully unite the progressive and moderate factions within the party to pass and implement the policies that Democratic voters want? Namely, affordable housing and healthcare, secure borders and expanded legal immigration pathways, anti-corruption reforms, campaign finance reforms, secure and equal voting rights, better wages and employment protections, stable prices, less war, reproductive rights… just a few little things! We’ll see, but probably not in the next two years, because Trump has promised to veto, veto, veto. 

Keep the questions coming! Submit yours here: Ask a Political Scientist Question Dropbox  – Fill out form Ask a Political Scientist Question Dropbox  – Collaboration

https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-new-liberals-how-the-democrats-lost-their-majority/ 

https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-polarization-paradox-elected-officials-and-voters-have-shifted-in-opposite-directions/