Letter to the Editor: Daniel Martinez
Editor’s note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the MSU Exponent, its editorial staff, advisers, or Montana State University.
I'm a Belgrade resident. Many young people in this valley already know Main Street: You drive it, you work there, you eat there. I want Main Street and Broadway left as it is. I am not asking for a traffic light.
Being invited to a public meeting is not the same as being heard before a decision is made. The City and Montana Department of Transportation (MDT) co-selected a mini-roundabout at Main and Broadway in March 2025, more than a year before the April 2026 open house. Most speakers at that meeting opposed it. A petition KBZK reported at about 700 signatures, and Eva Grace's petition of 1,410 asked that it not go in. MDT Director Larry Flynn wrote on Oct. 27 that the department is not planning to pause the project.
The Montana Constitution does not belong only to people who have already spent a lifetime here. It belongs to students, young workers and anyone else who lives with the result. A project scheduled for 2028 will still be here when today's students are raising families of their own. Article II, Section 1 says all political power is vested in and derived from the people. Article II, Section 8 gives the public the right to participate before a final decision is made. Sections 2-3-101, 2-3-103, and 2-3-111, MCA, require that input be considered first. In Bryan v. Yellowstone County Elementary School District No. 2 (2002 MT 264), the Montana Supreme Court held that this right requires more than an uninformed opportunity to speak. You do not have to hold office to have a right to be heard on a public project that will shape the town you live in now.
I asked what weight MDT gave the comment that came in. Director Flynn wrote that it is "not a matter of numerical weight, but a matter of context." He still has not stated that weight. Article II, Section 9 gives the public a right to know. I have asked for crash records, a cost split and traffic counts. Those records have not been provided.
MDT's March 2024 traffic report (Table 7) lists the mini-roundabout at $4.2 million, with a later estimate of $5,810,437. It would last only until 2057 and would remove 30 to 35 downtown parking spaces. The two most dangerous intersections in the City's own 2025 Safety Action Plan, Jackrabbit at Valley Center and Jackrabbit at Cameron Bridge, still have no funded construction project, while Main & Broadway, which didn't make the plan's top ten, is scheduled for construction first, in 2028.
If the right to participate does not apply until after a state agency has already chosen the project, it does not mean much for the people who will live with that decision the longest. I ask MDT to pause this project, finish the Jackrabbit work first, and leave Main and Broadway as it is.
Daniel Martinez
Belgrade
Comments ()