City commission approves grants with ICE cooperation clauses

Just before midnight on Tuesday, Nov. 17, the Bozeman City Commission unanimously voted to accept two grants from the federal government. The grants, identified in a memorandum to the commission as the 2025 Montana Department of Emergency Services (MTDES) HazMat Sustainment Grant Award and the 2025 Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Assistance to Firefighters Grant Award, would provide around $160,000 to the Bozeman Fire Department. 

According to the memorandum, the HazMat Sustainment Grant Award is part of the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) grant program administered by MTDES. The grant provides funds for maintaining training and equipment for the hazardous materials technician team’s response efforts. FEMA’s Assistance to Firefighters grant will provide early cancer screening for firefighters. The City Commission approved the grant applications in March 2025 and the awards are just now being implemented. 

Included in both of the grant’s language were attached clauses involving immigration, federal executive orders compliance and diversity, equity and inclusion. Specifically, the attached clauses would require the City of Bozeman to communicate and cooperate with immigration officials.  

City Attorney Greg Sullivan said the City does not have to change its current policies or practices to accept the grant. Further, Sullivan said the grant conditions are unlawful. Sullivan reported the terms of these grants have been brought to court by several local governments and states. According to Sullivan’s report in the memorandum, it has been found that the grants violate the Administrative Procedures Act. This process takes a significant amount of time and results have been appealed by the Federal Government.

“I think the City would be very successful in getting the court to say those conditions are unenforceable,” Sullivan said.

Before voting on the agenda item, the public was invited to provide public comment. Around 50 people spoke and many of them fully asked the commission to vote no. Several times during the meeting, commenters disrupted the event by interrupting speakers.

0:00
/2:42

Bozeman community member gives public comment on Tuesday, Nov. 17, where the Bozeman City Commission unanimously voted to accept two federal grants for the Bozeman Fire Department. The speaker raised concerns about the potential forced cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents under the clauses in the grant. / Videography by Gabe Weinrieb

Bill Jarosz, a Bozeman resident, was the first person to give public comment. “You are knowingly entering into a contract whose terms you do not intend to keep,” he told the commission. Jarosz said this would most likely result in a court case where the Montana Attorney General would not support the City. Further, Jarosz said that Bozeman would have significantly less resources in court than the federal government. Although Jarosz believes the City of Bozeman would win, the expenses of litigation would severely outweigh what is provided in the grants. 

Libby Kamalo, a Bozeman resident, said she believes the City should not have accepted the grant. “It's way more than a legal question. It's about the message sent to residents,” she said. 

William Frank McLean, a Bozeman resident, expressed to the commission that the grant money is not worth the legal trouble that may follow. “Why even let the devil in if you intend to kick him out,” he asked the commission. He said that $160,000 is less than one-tenth of the Bozeman general fund and believed that the City should look for alternative funding sources. 

0:00
/3:30

Tensions rose at the Nov. 17 City Commission meeting. Mayor Joey Morrison urged the audience to follow the meetings rules, which limit audience clapping or interrupting speakers. Community member Anthony Smit received two strikes for what Morrison described as disruptive behavior. / Videography by Gabe Weinrieb

Commissioner Emma Bode spoke with the Exponent after the meeting. “It feels exceptionally frustrating and wrong that the federal government, the executive branch, is trying to hold [funding] hostage from us by working in these completely unrelated and unlawful stipulations,” she said. 

At the meeting, Bode moved to vote on the grant. She said that the City of Bozeman is not safe from immigration enforcement with or without accepting the grant's conditions. Bode referenced events this summer when Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE) agents detained over 100 people in Bozeman, without the requirements in the grant or aid from the Bozeman Police Department.  

“I heard in public comment tonight that if one person gets taken away, that's too many, and I cannot agree more,” Bode said during her deliberation on why she moved to vote on the action. “Commenters have said that we cannot guarantee that this community will be safe from ICE if we accept this grant. We cannot guarantee that this community will be safe from ICE period — whether we accept this grant or not.” 

After the commission unanimously voted in favor, spectators in the room vocally expressed their opposition; many began chanting, “This commission needs to listen, this commission needs to listen.” 

In an interview with the Exponent after the event, Deputy Mayor Douglas Fischer said he voted for the grant — despite overwhelming disapproval in public comment — because he must provide for the other 59,000 people who live in Bozeman. He said none of the City policies will change and that he would go to court if needed but believes standing with immigrant communities is even more important. “What we really need to be is on the ground, you know, standing there in the barricades with our immigrant population, that's where we need to be, and that's where I would hope I would be,” he said. 

Bode said she is frustrated to be in this position, and recognizes that people feel disappointed with the commission. “If or when the feds come to try and enforce this, I'll show the community with my actions that my word means something,” Bode said.